Review: 'To God' by Esther Yi

Esther Yi remains queen of having fascinating images for her covers! With To God, she also continues to write confounding fiction, but there is also a new authorial calmness to her writing which is impressive. Thanks to Astra Publishing House and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of the house in exchange for an honest review.

Pub. Date: 13 October 2026
Publisher: Astra Publishing House

The cityscape of To God is in decay. There are drifters with nowhere to go and nothing to do, boxers with dreams of making it big (they won’t), artists who never get a chance to make art, women who frighten the men they love, and children who are more adult than the adults. Nothing goes right for these people—but what does going right mean anyway? After all, in the world of To God, it’s the loser who wins, the faceless who expresses, the atheist who truly believes, and the geriatric who’s reborn.

At the heart of To God is a voice, a beam of light that cuts through the entire collection to rearrange and reincarnate the world wherever it falls. Navigating the daily vicissitudes of work, love, and ideology, this voice asks: How do I know myself, and how do I know others? What does it feel like to know at all? What if I believe in nothing? Then what makes me live? Responsive to and born out of absence, this voice experiments with presence: a body, a personality, a set of relationships. Absence fuels the imagination, a kind of unbridled prayer, and this ritual becomes a stairway that the reader is invited to ascend, armed with an ever intensifying question to God, until the entire material world recedes out of view—only to reappear with greater urgency than before, openly necrotic and broken, itself a plane of mystery we can never call home, and its stakes all the more real for it.

To God illuminates the confused coordinates of contemporary life, its absurd contradictions, and our growing disconnectedness not only from each other but from our own selves. At the atomic level of language, the infrastructural level of genre play, and the cosmic level of existential threat, Esther Yi’s talent radiates.

Esther Yi's debut novel, Y/N, was quite divisive, I think. I had a very interesting reading experience with it, at once being impressed by her voice, which came through very strongly, and somewhat confused throughout. It was a novel that spoke deeply to the parasocial relationships people develop to celebrities and how this does not fill the gaping void at the heart of us. It was also deeply odd, somewhat abstract, and full of writing that I didn't always understand. Reactions to it varied as well, with some hailing Yi as a bright new voice and others not seeing the point of any of it. I felt myself to be somewhat in the middle, deeply intrigued by her voice and her ideas but not sure where it was going yet. With To God I feel like I am on more concrete ground with her and I find myself solidly in the camp of "oh yeah, this is going to be good". The oddity and verbosity that made Y/N and its writing so fascinating is still there, but there is also a certain calmness and control to it now. Crucially, this control does not stop Yi from coming up with bonkers ideas and working them out to their fullest.

To God is technically a short story collection but for me it almost felt like a continuous experience. The blurb sort of suggests this as well, by speaking of that "voice" that cuts through everything and in a sense that is indeed it. But I felt that the stories spoke to one another in a way that wasn't necessarily direct but was cohesive. Much as with Y/N, the stories here are concerned with alienation and distance, how we can live so close to each other in these cityscapes and yet run from real human engagement. They are also about physicality, the horrors and joys of being in a body, and the urge to create, to write, to make, to leave a mark, somehow, although that instinct is quite deeply buried at times. I don't necessarily want to go into the details of any of the stories because I very much enjoyed being surprised by where Yi took each of them. I will say that each of them is abstract and even absurd in its own way, not because they don't make any sense, but in the literary way, where they take something we might think is familiar and ask enough questions until the something loses all meaning. If that sounds like fun to you, then read To God, but don't do it to yourself if you if that doesn't sound fun.

Esther Yi's writing style probably isn't for everyone. I see her work labeled as "weird girl fiction" quite a bit and I can see why this is often meant as a compliment, but I don't know if I like it. There is weirdness to it, yes, but to me there is no sense of desired edginess. From reading To God I don't feel as if Yi is trying to get me to be confused, but rather she is trying to find ways to describe to me the experience of being in this world and not understanding it. Of wondering how we ended up where we are, why we do the things we do, why some things matter and others don't, why we have to keep grinding away at things. I don't think it is possible to try and capture that kind of feeling in any other way except writing that is somehow both very dense and verbose but also so light you lose its meaning if you don't pay attention. I mentioned above that it feels as if Yi is gaining increasing control over the effect of her language, comparing To God to Y/N and I am deeply excited to see where she takes this in future work.

I give this collection...

4 Universes!

I was unsure going into To God whether it would be for me, but I had a brilliant time with it. Was I still confused? Yes. But I was confused about this world before and through To God I have found some solidarity in that confusion. It won't be for everyone, but if you enjoyed parts of Y/N, then definitely give this a go!

Comments

Popular Posts